For the anti-profiling crusaders have created a headlong movement without defining their central term and without providing a shred of credible evidence that racial profiling is a widespread police practice. An argument against racial profiling essay - when people act on their stereotypical views, that is when stereotyping becomes a big concern and can affect othersstereotyping is the main cause that leads to profiling. Racial profiling encourages police to use a lower standard of evidence for blacks and latinos than they would for whites -- and this lower standard of evidence can easily lead police, private security, and armed citizens to respond violently to blacks and latinos out of a perceived self-defense concern. The arguments for racial profiling are based on statistics and, very generally, an argument about the best use of limited resources the increased screening of arabs is a perfectly sensible way to start the argument - is it possible that an 80 year old white grandma is going to try to blow up a plane. Racial profiling is a direct violation of the fourteenth amendment of the united state constitution and in some instances when racial profiling is used to search someone or their belongings it violates their fourth amendment as well.
On profiling's alleged irrationality3 for banks, the argument that racial profiling is irrational is mere masking rhetoric, obscuring underlying grievances about the consequences of profiling for minorities and minority. Should trial attorneys and experts condemn racial profiling as a police practice while condoning racial profiling in jury selection at trial as a british philosopher who has lived and worked in the united states, i offer some suggestions to help readers make the most of their expertise. Far from being a novel bit of truth-telling, the argument that black crime is the cause of reactionary policing is among the aged and easily refuted clichés of american racial history. The problem is, racial profiling isn't about a person being a certain race and committing a crime supposedly known to that race the problem is assuming that someone must have committed a certain crime because of their race.
Allegations of racial profiling have been around for years and still are a subject that creates a lot on media hype and controversy surrounding police racial profiling should not be mixed in with criminal profiling, because they are two different things (mucchetti, 2006, pp 1-32. This content was stolen from brainmasscom - view the original, and get the already-completed solution here describe the controversy surrounding racial profiling. General overviews racial profiling is a controversial policing topic that has produced a number of publications intended to inform the public, political officials, and law enforcement about the empirical and moral issues that surround it.
But there is a counter-argument, which has been articulated by former new york mayor michael bloomberg in defense of the city's stop and frisk program, namely that sometimes racial. Punitive crime policy, contact with law enforcement officers, profiling, and incarceration, etc i intend to study the history of crime policy in the us and whether or not racial bias within the criminal justice. Racial profiling in the dictionary is the assumption of criminality among ethnic groups: the alleged policy of some police to attribute criminal intentions to members of some ethnic groups and to stop and question them in disproportionate numbers without probable cause (racial profiling). Racial profiling is a longstanding and deeply troubling national problem despite claims that the united states has entered a post-racial era it occurs every day, in cities and towns across the country, when law enforcement and private security target people of color for humiliating and often frightening detentions, interrogations, and searches without evidence of criminal activity and.
The consequentialist perspective is at the heart of many arguments in favor of racial profiling israeli airline el al is known for its use of racial profiling, but also boasts a perfect track record of preventing hijackings and other onboard terrorist incidents (siggins, 2002. If you need to look only at the purpose and importance of racial profiling, there are two main types of argument that you should make first, you would need to argue that crime is a serious. There may be interesting arguments against profiling (or anti-profiling of the sort i recommend here), but i haven't noticed any amid the torrents of criticism i've received thus far if there is an expert on airline security who wants to set me straight, i am happy to offer this page as a forum.
Racial profiling has become a prominent issue in america after the incident with rodney king, more emphasis has been placed on profilingaccording to news reports, rodney king was driving down the street in his hometown of la when several police officers stopped him solely of the color of his skin. Racial discrimination in stop-and-frisk the city of new york, was filed by plaintiffs alleging racial profiling in street stops but judge scheindlin trenchantly rejected this argument. Racial skeptics like appiah and zack adopt normative racial eliminativism, which recommends discarding the concept of race entirely, according to the following argument because of its historical genealogy, the term race can only refer to one or more discrete groups of people who alone share biologically significant genetic features. High court hears arguments, and claims of racial profiling, in pot 'sniff test' case by alan j keays may 30 2018 june 2, 2018 share 18 tweet share email 18 shares.
See in the article it states that the officers were using criminal profiling which is indifferent to racial profilingthe definition of criminal profiling is offender profiling, also known as criminal profiling, is a behavioral and investigative tool that is intended to help investigators to accurately predict and profile the. An argument against racial profiling 2126 words | 9 pages racial profiling is when an officer of law targets an individual not on their behavior, but rather their personal characteristics, such as race, ethnicity, national origin and religion. The legal journals in particular provide a great deal of information on racial profiling and emphasize important distinctions between legal and moral arguments surrounding this issue. Profiling and the controversies surrounding the topic the following web sites and articles are good starting points to gather information and analyze the arguments.